Michele Pasin / Quotes

Time to bury the immaterial soul

To switch metaphors, if the soil is not proving to be fertile, it is better to plant elsewhere than to continue in the hope that persistence will bear fruit. In all my years of reading and thinking about soul and self, I’ve yet to come across a single argument that is left standing after even a little serious scrutiny. As an idea, the immaterial soul is dead, and it’s time we buried it, along with any other dreams we might have had about finding the pearl at the heart of our identity.

Saved 23 April 2015

#soul #dualism #self

Is my body essential to my identity

But is this body really essential to my identity? It seems at least possible to imagine that I might, like Gregor Samsa in the story by Kafka, wake up in a…

Mind: A Brief Introduction (John R. Searle) #personal-identity #self #soul #dualism

The ghost in the machine

Each mind is an immortal soul. Bodies, as physical entities, are determined by the laws of physics; but minds have free will. Each of us as a self is…

Mind: A Brief Introduction (John R. Searle) #dualism #self #soul #consciousness

Descartes denies that animals have minds

If every mind is a spiritual or mental substance, and if minds are indestructible, then it seems that if animals have minds, every animal has an immortal…

Mind: A Brief Introduction (John R. Searle) #animals #dualism #language #soul

Descartes divides the territory between science and religion

Cartesian dualism was important in the seventeenth century for a number of reasons, not the least of which being that it seemed to divide up the territory…

Mind: A Brief Introduction (John R. Searle) #dualism #science #religion #soul

Experts and the public disagree about dualism

The philosophy of mind has a special feature that distinguishes it from other branches of philosophy. In most philosophical subjects there is no sharp…

Mind: A Brief Introduction (John R. Searle) #dualism #soul #philosophers

Not like a pilot in a ship

In a famous passage Descartes said we should not think of the mind as lodged in the body like a pilot in a ship, but we should really think that it is somehow…

Mind: A Brief Introduction (John R. Searle) #dualism #soul #mind-body-problem