Michele Pasin / Quotes

Strong AI as a closet dualism

For Searle, to argue anything else means you must believe in a form of dualism, the position that the mental realm has no causal connection with the physical realm. According to Searle, this is precisely the position many AI researchers take. They believe that their models have a mental life purely on the basis of the right program being executed. Mental phenomena can be understood solely in terms of programs (mind), independent of machinery (brain).

Saved 15 June 2022 / www.amazon.com ↗

#dualism #artificial-intelligence #mind #brain

Computationalism as a form of dualism

Hardly any cognitive scientists are dualists in the Cartesian sense. While the Cartesians believed that the mind represented the world, they also believed it…

Beyond Zero and One (Andrew Smart) #dualism #computation #cognitive-science #mind

Descartes: not a sailor in a ship

a philosopher of Descartes’ undoubted genius is not going to completely miss the fact that this ego is very much embodied. In a passage often quoted by those…

The Ego Trick (baggini, Julian) #dualism #body #mind

Mind and body are not different orders

Descartes’ error was to think that mind and body are of different orders, not that mind exists.

The Ego Trick (baggini, Julian) #dualism #mind #body

Ryle's category mistake

But why is this apparently simple error so common? A convincing explanation was offered by Gilbert Ryle in his 1949 classic The Concept of Mind. Ryle accused…

The Ego Trick (baggini, Julian) #dualism #mind #language #categories

Swinburne: physicalism doesn't face the data

‘The trouble with physicalism,’ Swinburne told me, ‘is that it doesn’t face the data, and the data first of all is the mental life. We have thoughts and…

The Ego Trick (baggini, Julian) #materialism #dualism #mind

Team spirit and the ghost in the machine

My favourite of Ryle’s many examples is the person who understands that playing cricket requires team-spirit, but thinks that contributing team-spirit is an…

The Ego Trick (baggini, Julian) #dualism #mind #soul #categories