Michele Pasin / Quotes

A standard unit for measuring morality

‘Very well. I think that you can see my point here—we avoid chaos, in building houses and dividing land and so forth, by having an agreed standard for the measure of a unit of length. We call it a metre and, after many attempts, we decide upon a way to establish the length of that basic unit. In the same way, we can only avoid chaos in the world of human affairs by having an agreed standard for the measure of a unit of morality.’ ‘I’m with you.’ ‘At the moment, most of our ways of defining the unit of morality are similar in their intentions, but they differ in their details. So the priests of one nation bless their soldiers as they march to war, and the imams of another country bless their soldiers as they march out to meet them. And everybody who is involved in the killing, says that he has God on his side. There is no objective and universally acceptable definition of good and evil. And until we have one, we will go on justifying our own actions, while condemning the actions of the others.’ ‘And you’re putting the physics of the universe up as a kind of platinum-iridium bar?’ ‘Well, I do think that our definition is closer, in its precision, to the photon-second measure than it is to the platinum-iridium bar, but the point is essentially correct. I think that when we look for an objective way to measure good and evil, a way that all people can accept as reasonable, we can do no better than to study the way that the universe works, and its nature—the quality that defines the entire history of it—the fact that it is constantly moving towards greater complexity. We can do no better than to use the nature of the universe itself. And all the holy texts, from all the great religions, tell us to do this. The Holy Koran, for example, is often telling us, instructing us, to study the planets and the stars to find truth and meaning.’

Saved 5 November 2015

#measures #morality

Accuracy versus precision

is important to keep in mind the difference between accuracy and precision. Accuracy refers to how close a measurement is to its true value; precision refers…

Beyond Zero and One (Andrew Smart) #measures #science #method

Altmetrics

Peer-review has served scholarship well, but is beginning to show its age. It is slow, encourages conventionality, and fails to hold reviewers accountable…

Altmetrics: A Manifesto – Altmetrics.org #measures #impact

Citation analysis

Ever since the idea of using citations for research evaluation was introduced [Garfield,1955], citation analysis has received a lot of attention and many…

A New Semantic Similarity Based Measure For Assessing Research Publication’s Contribution #citations #evaluation #measures #analysis #attention

IQ is a dress size, not a birth date

Like Kirstie’s dress size, IQ is malleable. IQ has been shown to vary over one’s life span, and it is surprisingly vulnerable to environmental influences. It…

Brain Rules for Baby (John Medina) #intelligence #environment #family #measures

IQ tests miss most of intelligence

From exploration, self-control, and creativity to verbal and nonverbal ability, it is clear that the intelligence stew has many ingredients. Standard IQ tests…

Brain Rules for Baby (John Medina) #intelligence #measures #children

Intelligence is a stew, not a number

Harvard psychologist Howard Gardner, who published his latest theory of multiple intelligences in 1993, put it this way: Strong evidence exists “that the mind…

Brain Rules for Baby (John Medina) #intelligence #mind #measures