Michele Pasin / Quotes

Minds are just brains

The sheer implausibility of behaviorism had become an embarrassment by the 1960s and it was gradually replaced among materialist-minded philosophers by a doctrine called “physicalism,” sometimes called the “identity theory.” The physicalists said that Descartes was not wrong, as the logical behaviorists had claimed, as a matter of logic, but just as a matter of fact. It might have turned out that we had souls in addition to bodies, but the way that nature in fact turned out, what we think of as minds are just brains, and what we think of as mental states, such as the feeling of pain or having a tickle or an itch, are just states of the brain—and perhaps the rest of the central nervous system. This thesis was sometimes called the “identity thesis” because it asserted an identity between mental states and brain states.

Saved 30 July 2014 / www.amazon.com ↗

#identity-theory #materialism #brain

Soul as light bulb, brain as socket

‘What I have argued,’ he writes, ‘… is that without a functioning brain, the soul will not function (i.e. have conscious episodes) – not that it will not…

The Ego Trick (baggini, Julian) #soul #brain #dualism #materialism

The self as a verb dressed as a noun

It seems the only way to make sense of this is that mental events emerge from physical ones, without being strictly identical with them. As the neurologist…

The Ego Trick (baggini, Julian) #emergence #materialism #self #brain

A complete account is more than a physical one

It should be clear that this argument simply repeats the kind of category mistake identified by Ryle. So it is true, as Swinburne says, that a physical…

The Ego Trick (baggini, Julian) #materialism #dualism #description #categories

Christians without dualist souls

Having dismissed the idea that we have immaterial souls, you might assume that there is nothing left to be said for the Christian idea of a life to come…

The Ego Trick (baggini, Julian) #Christianity #soul #dualism #materialism

Dissolving the divide between subjective and objective

But the divide between subjective and objective could also turn out to be an illusion of our own creation. This division goes to the core of our scientific…

Beyond Zero and One (Andrew Smart) #materialism #consciousness #psychedelics #objectivity

Eliminative materialists feign anaesthesia

The first is that thoughts, feelings, emotions and so on are real. There are some ‘eliminative materialists’ who claim that they aren’t, but in I.A…

The Ego Trick (baggini, Julian) #materialism #mind #feelings