Michele Pasin / Quotes

Dualists and materialists make the same mistake

People who accept the reality and irreducibility of the mental tend to think of themselves as dualists. But to others, accepting an irreducible mental component in reality seems like giving up on the scientific world-view, so they deny the existence of any such mental reality. They think it can all be reduced to the material or eliminated altogether. They tend to think of themselves as materialists. I think both sides are making the same mistake. I am going to try to overcome the vocabulary and the assumptions, and in so doing I am going to try to solve or dissolve the traditional problems. But once we do that, the subject, the philosophy of mind, does not end: it gets more interesting. And this is my second reason for wanting to write this book.

Saved 30 July 2014 / www.amazon.com ↗

#dualism #materialism #philosophy-of-mind

A complete account is more than a physical one

It should be clear that this argument simply repeats the kind of category mistake identified by Ryle. So it is true, as Swinburne says, that a physical…

The Ego Trick (baggini, Julian) #materialism #dualism #description #categories

Christians without dualist souls

Having dismissed the idea that we have immaterial souls, you might assume that there is nothing left to be said for the Christian idea of a life to come…

The Ego Trick (baggini, Julian) #Christianity #soul #dualism #materialism

Hofmann on the West's spiritual crisis

Hofmann strongly believed that there was a spiritual crisis in Western civilization, and argued that society must shift from “the materialistic, dualistic…

Beyond Zero and One (Andrew Smart) #spirituality #materialism #dualism #nature #psychedelics

Soul as light bulb, brain as socket

‘What I have argued,’ he writes, ‘… is that without a functioning brain, the soul will not function (i.e. have conscious episodes) – not that it will not…

The Ego Trick (baggini, Julian) #soul #brain #dualism #materialism

Swinburne: physicalism doesn't face the data

‘The trouble with physicalism,’ Swinburne told me, ‘is that it doesn’t face the data, and the data first of all is the mental life. We have thoughts and…

The Ego Trick (baggini, Julian) #materialism #dualism #mind

Are computations real or epistemic tools?

In philosophy, cognitive science, and, more broadly speaking, in computer science, there is a divide between those who believe that computations underlie…

Beyond Zero and One (Andrew Smart) #computation #information #reality #philosophy-of-mind