Michele Pasin / Quotes

Quantitative measure of scientific impact

One can also program the computer to “erase” one or more nodes and its connections in the network. By making the assumption that any papers which derive from these nodes should also be erased, one can then determine whether an alternate “critical path” to a subsequent discovery does exist. Thus, one can legitimately ask whether the work of Whitnah on the physical properties of milk22 or Elworthy ’s work on lecithin micelles23 would have been possible if Einstein had not published his paper on measuring dimensions of molecules! 24 Further, by counting the totaJ number of “terminal” nodes erased, onc may possibly obtain a useful quantitative measure of historical impact. A terminal node is a member of a particular set of papers, as, e.g., all 1962 papers. The critical impact of Einstein’ s work would be the percentage of 1962 papes which, one assumes, would not have been written if they could not have cited either Einstein’s papers or papers which have cited Einstein. In making such calculations, one has to also consider the papers cited by Einstein.

Saved 5 January 2015 / garfield.library.upenn.edu ↗

#nodes #impact #measures

Altmetrics

Peer-review has served scholarship well, but is beginning to show its age. It is slow, encourages conventionality, and fails to hold reviewers accountable…

Altmetrics: A Manifesto – Altmetrics.org #measures #impact

Citations are insufficient evidence of impact, quality and research contribution

However, citations are one of many attributes surrounding a publication and by themselves provide an insufficient evidence of impact, quality and research…

A New Semantic Similarity Based Measure For Assessing Research Publication’s Contribution #citations #attributes #evidence #impact

Impact depends on content, not interactions

In this paper, we present an approach for assessing the impact of a paper based on its full-text (Section 2). In this context, we use the term impact to refer…

A New Semantic Similarity Based Measure For Assessing Research Publication’s Contribution #impact #number #manuscript #interaction #content

Judging a paper without reading it

The use of the current research publications performance metrics (citations, altmetrics, webometris, etc) is, in our opinion, based on a false premise that…

A New Semantic Similarity Based Measure For Assessing Research Publication’s Contribution #use #assumption #impact

Blank node identifiers

Since a complex graph might contain more than one blank node, there also needs to be a way to differentiate between these different blank nodes in a triples…

Rdf Primer #nodes #identifiers #subjects #form #results